Price Guide
"What is the value of my card?"
Willie Mays 1958 Topps #486 All-Star SGC 5 Price Guide
Last Sale: $101.00 2/20/2025
30 Day Change: +$0.00
Loading..
Recent Sales of Willie Mays 1958 Topps #486 All-Star SGC 5
Â
ÂNNN.NN
Â
ÂNNN.NN
The Willie Mays 1958 Topps #486 All-Star card in PSA 7 condition has not changed in price in the last 30 days and was last sold for $569.95 .
This card is 1 of 2 Willie Mays' card variations in the 1958 Topps set being tracked by Sports Card Investor, including Base.
Other popular players in the 1958 Topps set include Al Kaline, Ernie Johnson Sr., Bill Mazeroski, Bill Tuttle, and Billy Martin.
Auctions Ending Soon for Willie Mays 1958 Topps #486 All-Star SGC 5
We receive a commission for purchases made.
Â
Â
NNN.NN
Â
Â
NNN.NN
Â
Â
NNN.NN
Best Prices Available For Sale of Willie Mays 1958 Topps #486 All-Star
We receive a commission for purchases made.
PSA 8
Last Sale$1.00K1/11/2025Last 14 AvgN/APSA 7
Last Sale$5703/15/2025Last 14 AvgN/APSA 6
Last Sale$2393/30/2025Last 14 Avg$2391958 Topps Willie Mays ALL-STAR #486 PSA 6 EXMT
$279
Psa 6 1958 Topps Willie Mays All-Star # 486 nicer
$280
1958 Topps #486 Willie Mays All-Star PSA 6 EX-MT San Francisco Giants / HOF
$300
1958 Topps Willie Mays ALL-STAR #486 PSA 6 EXMT
$305
1958 TOPPS # 486 Willie Mays PSA 6 EX-MT # 100342726 SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS !!!
$455
1958 Topps #486 Willie Mays All-Star Sport Magazine PSA 6 Graded Baseball Card
$800
- Shop this card
- Shop this card
PSA 5.5
Last Sale$1041/25/2025Last 14 AvgN/APSA 4.5
Last Sale$1506/18/2024Last 14 AvgN/APSA 4
Last Sale$73.003/22/2025Last 14 Avg$73.001958 WIllie Mays Topps #486 PSA 4 - NEW LABEL - Freshly Graded
$99.00
1958 TOPPS #486 WILLIE MAYS ALL STAR PSA 4 HOF
$99.95
1958 TOPPS #486 WILLIE MAYS ALL STAR PSA 4 HOF
$130
1958 Topps WILLIE MAYS AS #486 PSA 4
$139
1958 Topps #486 WILLIE MAYS Psa 4 All Star Giants FRESHLY GRADED !!
$175
1958 Topps #486 Willie Mays All-Star Sport Magazine PSA 4 Graded Baseball Card
$205
- Shop this card
- Shop this card
PSA 3
Last Sale$75.003/29/2025Last 14 Avg$64.55PSA 2
Last Sale$50.003/26/2025Last 14 Avg$52.001958 Topps - #486 Willie Mays ALL STAR - San Francisco Giants - PSA 2
$69.99
1958 TOPPS AS #486 WILLIE MAYS PSA 2
$70.00
1958 Topps #486 Willie Mays San Francisco Giants All-Star HOF PSA 2 GOOD
$97.30
1958 Topps #486 Willie Mays All Star Graded PSA 2 San Francisco Giants HOF
$120
1958 Topps Sport Magazine '58 All Star Selection Willie Mays #486 PSA 2 HOF
$175
- Shop this card
- Shop this card
PSA 1.5
Last Sale$40.003/27/2025Last 14 Avg$40.00PSA 1
Last Sale$33.682/15/2025Last 14 AvgN/A1958 Topps Willie Mays All Star #486 PSA 1 PR HOF SF Giants Legend!
$51.96
1958 Topps Willie Mays All Star #486 PSA 1 HOF NEWLY GRADED 👀
$64.99
WILLIE MAYS PSA 1 1958 TOPPS BASEBALL #486 SAN FRANCESCO GIANTS TRUE LEGEND
$65.00
1958 Topps Willie Mays All Star #486 PSA 1 HOF NEW SLAB
$79.00
- Shop this card
- Shop this card
BVG 3
Last SaleN/ALast 14 AvgN/ASGC 6.5
Last Sale$21412/12/2024Last 14 AvgN/ASGC 6
Last Sale$21512/2/2024Last 14 AvgN/ASGC 5
Last Sale$1012/20/2025Last 14 AvgN/A1958 TOPPS #486 WILLIE MAYS ALL-STAR San Francisco Giants SGC 5 EX NICE!
$140
1958 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS SGC 5 EX ALL STAR # 486 SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS
$200
Willie Mays 1958 Topps All Star #486 SGC 5 🔥🔥 San Francisco Giants
$200
1958 Topps Baseball #486 Willie Mays All-Star SGC 5 EX (Sharp Corners)
$215
1958 Topps WILLIE MAYS All Star San Francisco Giants #486 SGC 5 EX Condition!
$230
- Shop this card
- Shop this card
SGC 4
Last Sale$77.003/4/2025Last 14 AvgN/ASGC 2
Last Sale$50.0012/12/2024Last 14 AvgN/A

Most popular Willie Mays Cards
Brought to you byMarket Movers
Â
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/AÂ
Â
Â7 DAYSN/A30 DAYSN/A
Baseball Sets featuring Willie Mays
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
Cards by Category
